The Addy ruling: when working holiday makers may use resident tax rates

Some working holiday makers can be taxed on the same basis as an Australian resident national. The High Court’s Addy decision of 3 November 2021 supports that treatment where the relevant tax treaty protects the person and their circumstances satisfy the rule. It does not give every working holiday maker a tax-free threshold.

This article covers the rules from 3 November 2021. Examples and links checked 10 November 2026.

What the High Court decided

In Addy v Commissioner of Taxation [2021] HCA 34, the taxpayer was a United Kingdom national holding a working holiday visa. She was an Australian resident for tax purposes for the income year in question. That residency was not disputed in the High Court.

The Australia–United Kingdom treaty included a non-discrimination rule. The Court held that imposing more burdensome tax on her than on an Australian national in the same circumstances breached that rule. The special working holiday maker rates therefore did not apply to her for the 2017 income year.

The important distinction is between immigration status and tax status. A visa tells you the basis on which you may enter or stay in Australia. Tax residency is a separate assessment. A person can hold a temporary visa and still be a tax resident, but the visa itself does not settle the question.

Why two people on similar visas can have different tax bills

Start with three questions: were you an Australian tax resident during the relevant period, what nationality do you hold for treaty purposes, and does an applicable treaty provide the necessary protection for that income year? Two travellers doing similar work can reach different answers.

For a simple illustration, consider $30,000 of working holiday taxable income in 2021–22. Under the standard working holiday maker bracket, 15% of $30,000 is $4,500. Using full-year ordinary resident brackets instead, the first $18,200 is tax free and 19% of the remaining $11,800 is $2,242.

The difference is $2,258 before offsets, Medicare and any other adjustments. This is an illustration of bracket arithmetic, not a calculation of Ms Addy’s assessment or a promised refund. A part-year resident, someone with other income or someone changing visa categories needs a more detailed calculation. The historical Income Tax Rates Act tables record the 2021–22 brackets used here.

Later ATO guidance, checked in November 2026, explains the eligible treaty countries and conditions. Check the relevant year’s treaty position rather than applying today’s country list automatically to an earlier return.

What to check before changing a return

Keep your visa history, travel dates, accommodation arrangements, work records and original assessments together. These help establish which periods and income are involved. Simply staying longer than six months is not enough information to conclude that the resident rules apply; the ATO’s working holiday residency guidance explains the wider assessment.

Use our working holiday maker tables and resident rate tables after establishing which treatment applies. The Australian income tax calculator uses ordinary resident rates. It cannot decide treaty eligibility or calculate standard working holiday maker tax, and 2021–22 is not an available calculator year.

If an earlier assessment may be affected, confirm the available amendment or objection process and its time limits with the ATO or a registered tax agent. The useful first step is establishing entitlement for the particular year, before estimating how much tax might change.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *