Historical event: 14 June 2023. Sources and calculator scope checked on 11 November 2026. The later CDC explanation below is background, not part of the AMA announcement.
On 14 June 2023, the American Medical Association announced a policy clarifying the role of BMI in medicine. It recommended considering BMI alongside other valid measures of risk. For someone looking at a calculator result, the practical point is that one number cannot describe their whole health.
What the AMA was concerned about
The policy recognized limitations in the historical populations used to develop BMI and harms associated with its use, including racist exclusion. It also noted differences in body shape and composition across populations, sexes, genders and ages. A measure that helps describe patterns across a population can be less informative when applied to one person.
The AMA listed other measures that can contribute to assessment, including waist circumference, body composition and metabolic factors. It also said BMI should not be the sole reason to deny appropriate insurance reimbursement. The announcement did not say that BMI should disappear from medical practice; it asked clinicians to understand its strengths and limitations.
What the calculation leaves out
BMI divides weight in kilograms by height in metres squared. The calculation is straightforward. For example, an adult weighing 80 kg (about 176 lb) at 1.75 m (about 5 ft 9 in) has a BMI of 80 ÷ (1.75 × 1.75), or about 26.1 kg/m². The arithmetic gives the same result regardless of that person’s symptoms, fitness, blood pressure or medical history.
The CDC’s later BMI explanation, dated 16 December 2025, describes BMI as a screening measure and explains that it does not distinguish fat from muscle and bone. It does not show where fat is carried. CDC recommends considering medical history, examination findings and laboratory results as part of an individual’s assessment.
That distinction matters when two people have the same BMI. They share a weight-to-height ratio; they do not necessarily share the same body composition or health concerns. A calculator has no way to resolve those differences from height and weight alone.
Use a result to prepare a conversation
The adult BMI calculator uses WHO adult categories and is available for people aged 18 and over. It provides a screening result, not a diagnosis or a treatment decision. Use measured height and weight in the correct units, then read the category together with the tool’s limitations.
For the 80 kg (about 176 lb) example, a result around 26.1 falls in the standard adult overweight screening category. That label does not establish whether the person has a disease, needs medication or should pursue a particular weight. Those questions need information the calculator does not collect. Children need age-specific interpretation. At ages 18–19, adult and adolescent references overlap; use the reference recommended by their healthcare team.
- Ask what the BMI result contributes to your assessment.
- Discuss symptoms, relevant family history and changes over time.
- Ask whether waist measurement or other assessment would add useful information.
- Agree on the next step and how progress will be assessed.
You do not need to order a collection of tests yourself because a screening category appeared on a screen. Bring the result to an appropriate health appointment if you have concerns. The AMA policy supports interpreting the number in context so that decisions respond to the person’s health needs.
Leave a Reply